Angry Jack's vs Tough Leather Cap is pretty even, to me. I think it comes down to whether you want Blind Rage in your deck or not. Lately I'm leaning on no to that question for the decks I'm playing, so I'm not running it. But when I do run Blind Rage I think it's plainly one of the better hats, and frequently worth the token. Tough Leather Cap is solid though, and I think it's very comparable.