Card Ideas

Discussion in 'Feedback and Suggestions' started by timeracers, Jan 2, 2015.

  1. tolkien

    tolkien Thaumaturge

    fatcat__25 and ParodyKnaveBob like this.
  2. ParodyKnaveBob

    ParodyKnaveBob Thaumaturge

    Perhaps "Diversity" could be named "Battle, Soldier!" ? $:^ J
     
  3. tolkien

    tolkien Thaumaturge

    Diversify, Soldier!

    I meant to put something in about requiring a human, elf, and a dwarf but couldn't figure out how to word it. We have cards that check for elves and dwarves. What about one that checks for diversity as a human skill? Suggestions for wording...?
     
    ParodyKnaveBob likes this.
  4. Frostguard

    Frostguard Thaumaturge

    I also like Battle, Soldier!, but I think that it's a bit off in the sense that every Do Something, Soldier! card targets a single target, while this one affects every ally. How about Call to Arms or Rally?

    On that note, the synergy with Leadership is uncanny! This would also show up on human skills, which limits that somewhat. But what about an item with this card, Leadership, and, say, Vanguard (all right, I certainly am pushing this, aren't I).

    As for the diversity part, hard to tell. What about something like...
    If you have an ally that's an elf and an ally that's a dwarf, create a Bludgeon and a Block in each ally's hand?
    A bit clunky, but I believe it gets the job done.

    But in that case, I'd still change the name somewhat. Diversify, Soldier! feels a bit odd for two reasons, one is the reason mentioned above that this does not target a single character, and the other is that as you play the card, you're not diversifying; your group is already diverse, and that's what grants you the advantage (I'm nitpicking, I know, but I'm just trying to explain something rather than just being annoying, if you can believe that). I'd probably go with a name like Strength in Diversity or Cooperation or something like that.

    That said, I think there's the important question whether this checks for dead allies. If it doesn't, then this (probably quite high-quality, at least based on the sheer volume of cards it creates) card does absolutely nothing as soon as you're one character down, which could be a serious hit to how powerful it could be. I like the idea, though, and it does seem to encourage diverse deckbuilding so I can definitely get behind that.

    I've also had a few ideas recently. I have boring ones and even more boring ones, so everyone can rejoice!

    Serendipity
    Assist
    Discard a card, then draw two cards.
    "Quick wit is every bit as useful in the heat of battle as quick hands." - Captain Cedric Cleavehorn

    Notes: This certainly feels like a card for human skills. I guess notably, it's card parity compared to the (technical) card disadvantage on Leadership, but the scale is also much smaller and it doesn't help allies, so it feels fair. Obviously this is pretty good with Officer's Harness for example, but that does assume that you're running Officer's Harness. Wind Dancer might be more problematic, but I do think that since Leadership already exists and isn't broken (despite also comboing with Officer's Harness and Wind Dancer), Serendipity definitely shouldn't be a problem. Leadership has Free Draw, but it also has card disadvantage; with Serendipity, I feel that one of its draws should be Free Draw and the other should not (traits aren't free draw, either), so I decided not to go with any.

    Clinging Flame
    Attack, Magic Fire, Damage 1, Range 5
    Burning 2, Duration 4.
    "You know that little tune that keeps going on in your head no matter what you do? This is like that, except it's also fire." - Adze the Lonely

    Notes: Definitely of the even more boring variety. Design-wise it really doesn't have a lot to go for it. It's more of a comment on how similar the fire cards we have are. Single-target burning 3, burst burning 2, and that's basically it. It's especially odd to me how Flame Spit is basically just a worse Flame Jet, as it's the same burning and the same duration, but it trades the ability to hit multiple targets for one more point of initial damage, a trade that I don't think is good. Clinging Flame in a vacuum is worse than Glob of Flame (same amount of damage spread over a longer time) but obviously things change as other synergy cards enter the scene. I wonder how good this would be?

    Still the Flames
    Utility, Magic Fire
    At the start of the next turn, Burning cards you control deal no damage and don't lose duration.
    "Of course, many imagine that pyromancy is all about going mad and burning everything in your path without consideration. Some certainly follow that principle, but I believe that forethought and control are as useful as they are on every other field of magic." - Oberlin Ninetower

    Notes: This is maybe a little less boring but probably entirely stupid. Still, you know what this is for.

    Pyrokinesis
    Attack, Magic Fire, Damage 1, Range 6
    Trigger all Burning cards attached to target, then create a copy of one of them randomly and attach it to another target character.
    "My flames will dance with you." - Akon the Pyromonius

    Notes: Have I mentioned that I hopelessly like fire cards?
     
    ParodyKnaveBob and fatcat__25 like this.
  5. Kalin

    Kalin Begat G'zok

    How about this?

    Brainstorm
    Assist, Magic
    Draw a card, Free Draw. Draw an additional card (not free) for each ally within 3 squares that is a different race or class than you.
     
    ParodyKnaveBob, tolkien and Sir Veza like this.
  6. squirrat

    squirrat Orc Soldier

    Ring of Water
    Magic Arcane
    All terrain that is adjacent to target square becomes Water Terrain (Water Terrain is impassable). Target square does not become Water Terrain.
    "Hope you didn't want to go anywhere." - Rey the Noob
     
    ParodyKnaveBob and Sir Veza like this.
  7. Sir Veza

    Sir Veza Farming Deity

    How about: "Imagine Venice without a gondola."
     
    ParodyKnaveBob likes this.
  8. ParodyKnaveBob

    ParodyKnaveBob Thaumaturge

    I was a bit out of it when reading earlier. Whoops! I didn't even register the original "Diversity" dealing with multiple allies. In that case... Lemme merge some ideas...

    (use the Good For Us graphic)
    (silver-ish quality? gold-ish quality? emerald-ish quality? it's solid, but it's not Delegate by any means)
    (worded for forward-compatibility with monsters in Campaign, Mauve Manticore, League, etc.)
    (intended for Human Skills)
    The word serendipity carries a meaning of "good luck." We all know from Leadership that sometimes a discard->draw can grant no such luck at all. Lol. $X^ D
    Hey hey! Maybe this!! $:^ D

    These then come to mind...

    human skill item:
    Diverse Flexibility
    - Leadership
    - Unite, Team!
    - ??? (depends on Unite's value - if silver-ish, then maybe Battlefield Training or Retreat - if much higher, then maybe a black or paper card that stays in hand, like Ill-fitting Armor or Wounded Block, I dunno)

    Trained Guidance
    Uncommon, Level 12-ish (minortoken)
    - Leadership
    - Block, Soldier!
    - Attack, Soldier!

    Meanwhile, all this Human, Soldier! discussion made me realize we're missing something, and then while I gathered stuff to put it together, I realized .. it could be made more flavorful, universe-consistent, and just plain interesting.

    Zap, Soldier!
    Assist, Paper quality, Uncommon
    Projectile Sonic
    Range 5
    If target is a Wizard, create and put a Zap card in target's hand. If target is not a Wizard, create and put an Arcane Feedback card in target's hand.
    "This will probably help!" - Aloyzo the wizard

    It could be funny to do the same with healing, but 1. there's at least precedent for non-Wizards getting Arcane Feedbacks, and 2. is there any "bad" heal besides Misguided Heal which is often better than Heal and lower anyway. (And yes, I know Arcane Feedback has double the range of Zap. But still.)

    Fun discussions, folks. $:^ ]
     
    Last edited: Oct 29, 2019
    fatcat__25 and Sir Veza like this.
  9. Frostguard

    Frostguard Thaumaturge

    Ring of Water definitely needs to specify that unoccupied squares around the target square become Water terrain, unless you want to drown people. Which is I guess acceptable, but doesn't have a precedent in the game thus far, sadly.

    Brainstorm seems good to me, but in fact a bit too generous. Unless you're running one of those parties with three identical characters (regarding race and class), this is going to net you at least one card (provided the distance requirement is met), and even a triple warrior team with three different races draws two cards off of this. I actually wouldn't mind it without the race/class clause, either, at an appropriately high quality, though with the name Brainstorm it really could go either way. Well done!

    As far as I remember, serendipity could have connotations of good luck but usually what I associated it with is looking for something and finding something completely different (but not bad), which is what I had in mind when I named the card. A quick look on Wiktionary confirms as much. Revised Thinking is also a good name, if Serendipity is still not acceptable I'd probably go with something like Improvise.

    It's only tangentially related to the discussion, but while there are cases of bad luck with Leadership, my opinion is that the card is badly underrated in general and is much better than it gets credit for, and especially good when looking for specific cards that are only needed temporarily (I wonder when that could happen). On the other hand, we have Delegate these days, which makes just about everything moot.

    I quite like Zap, Soldier!, but I was thinking about the healing part too. How do we make that? Maybe I'm just overdoing the whole thing, but here's an idea.

    First Aid
    Assist, Range 1
    Heal 2.
    "You won't always have a priest or a healer at your beck and call. If you want to survive your first battle, it's a good idea to learn the basics of how to stem bleeding and stop wounds from getting worse until you can get the assistance you need." - Captain Cedric Cleavehorn

    Notes: I'm in trouble regarding card types. It's definitely not Magic (that's the point), but would it feel right to classify this as either Melee or Projectile? Melee is closest to truth but still feels silly, and this should definitely not be Holy - so what should it be? I just left it blank. We have cards like that, such as Push the Button. Misguided Heal would work here so well for one reason, but not really for a bunch of others, unfortunately.

    Heal, Soldier!
    Assist, Projectile Sonic, Range 5
    Create a First Aid card and put it into the target's hand.
    "We're stopping here to set up a camp, but if I see just one soldier running around with untended wounds, you don't want to know what's going to happen."

    All of this just gave me an idea.

    Sonorous
    Boost
    Trait. Attach this card to yourself. Increase the range of Sonic cards you play by two. Duration 3.
    "When he speaks, the whole world listens, mainly because it has no other choice."
     
    ParodyKnaveBob and Sir Veza like this.
  10. ParodyKnaveBob

    ParodyKnaveBob Thaumaturge

    Sonorous is awesome. $E^ b

    First Aid looks good to me. I wonder if Heal 3 (or 4?) would be okay since it's range 1. Melee Holy might look a touch weird, but it's appropriate. Range 1 Projectile Holy? ~shrug~ We have Range 1 Magic cards after all - not to mention Everybody Drink!
     
  11. tolkien

    tolkien Thaumaturge

    In Dungeons and Dragons there are healing potions that cross classes.

    Health Potion
    Assist
    Projectile Holy
    You heal 4.

    Magic Potion
    Assist
    Projectile Arcane
    Damage 4. Range 3

    Energy Potion
    Assist (doesn't count as a move card)
    Projectile Sonic
    Move 4.
     
    ParodyKnaveBob likes this.
  12. Fanturluche

    Fanturluche Thaumaturge

    Potions may take time to drink. How about using them between rounds?

    Healing Potion
    Projectile Poison
    Range 1. Give the Healing Potion to target.
    At the start of round, if you are injured, heal 4. Free card.
     
  13. Kalin

    Kalin Begat G'zok

    First, I'm limiting the card to Human Skills, so choosing this means not choosing Delegate or Leadership. Also, to get three in your party you need to play an all human 1/1/1 team. Is anyone doing this now?

    Sounds more like Potion of Stalling. How about the much simpler:
    Attach to target, duration 1. At the start of the round, Heal 4.

    What kinds of items would have these potion cards?
     
    ParodyKnaveBob likes this.
  14. tolkien

    tolkien Thaumaturge

    This is for when we turn treasure into a slot on the player sheet that adds one card to your deck. =^}
     
    fatcat__25 likes this.
  15. fatcat__25

    fatcat__25 Kobold

    That idea intrigues me. How do you propose that it would work?
     

Share This Page