Major tokens to go weapons. No argue there. What do you consider a best weapon for warrior that uses at least 1 Major (Yellow) Token?
I vote for Bejeweled as most consistent, followed by Vibrant Pain as a weapon that opens lots of possibilities (for dw at least). (maybe Reaper's Scythe in Top3, but I just recently got one, never played with it so I dont have a feeling about it yet )
I like Reaper's Scythe a lot less post-Dodge nerf and Obliterating Bludgeon->Pulverizing Bludgeon, but it's not a bad weapon. I have an Axe Of The Titans, but I never use it -- I don't love Obliterating Chop in MP, and in SP, I'd rather use Bloodchopper or another item with chops.
Axe of Titans- Useless, would never use. Reapers Scythe- Still good, but hurt by dodge nerf. Quick Jons- As above, even weaker than Reapers though, probably no real place for it. Bloodchopper- Would only be useful on a small map, of which there are none in ranked mp, in chess madness or triple threat, this is a great weapon. Vibrant pain- Still powerful, just wish it was 5 damage not 4. Hackmaster- Without that one elite aspect to distinguish it from strongarm, it is now close to useless. Bludgeonator- Just playable if you supplement movement, you probably want crusher for max effect also. Crazy Sals- Its different, i like that, and it can be used in many ways. Lunginator- Not a bad all around weapon. But compare damage to: Bejeweled- Enough said, (see my post, shameless plug) You did leave out Double edged sword, which is probably 2nd after bejeweled
I feel that the list is leaving out Blocking Mace, as it's one of the best, if not THE best anti-warrior weapon. Combine that with the popularity of warriors these days, and you have useful weapon with cycling, damage prevention, and card advantage!
Obliterating chop is brilliant in Chess Madness and some of the other tight VP maps, especially if you disguise it by taking a dummy trait like impaling. Bejewelled and VP are the obvious choices. Lunginator and Crazy Sal's can be handy. Agree with Grim about Master's Battleaxe > Axe of the Titans. Basically the big weapons need tech, so the techless weapons and those with nerfed tech like dodge are at a disadvantage.
