I've created a second party, dressed them in the best they can wear out of my L20 first party's used gear, and run through all the Level 1 dungeons. In all four cases, not only was there no club reward loot -- there wasn't a club reward -section-. No key sigil, no square cushion, no label. The interface does helpfully inform me that I have 3 days left of my club membership. Is this working as intended?
Disregard, I see it was intentional. Those adventures happen before Gary introduces the Club Rewards thing in the first place.
Correct, however - it wouldn't hurt if it was shown there was a reason for it not being there on replays.
Probably because the LV1 quests always have predetermined drops. You always get the exact same items every time.
No, it's because the Club isn't introduced until at the end of the tutorial. So probably hardcoded, and not related to what loot's set for the adventure.
LV1s don't have the same rewards every time. Especially the last one. I've gotten rare treasure from it as well as other items. The first couple may have predetermined drops however...
Raid on Ommlet always drops Pickled Herring, but the others are random. However, they're choosing from a small set, so you'll get a lot of Woodsman's Axes.